It’s a riff on a black Manhattan for the black smoke from the papal conclave.

FUMATA NERA

1 oz blended or highland scotch 1 oz Islay Scotch 3/4 oz Amaro Averna 1/8 oz allspice dram
Chocolate bitters Black walnut bitters Orange twist garnish

Stirred and served up.

It’s dry, but just enough sweetness from the Averna to make it work. I’d go back for another!